What Charterers Need to Know About Seafarer Welfare
Evidence about rest, working conditions and the freedom to raise a safety concern could change how charterers compare ships and how insurers understand risk at sea.
Two vessels meet a charterer’s requirements and are available at the same rate. The particulars set out what each ship can carry, and the offer gives a window for loading. Finding out who covers the next watch after a long port call takes a different kind of enquiry. It is a question of seafarer welfare with consequences for how the voyage is run, and it is one of the harder things to establish from ashore.
Ellie Besley-Gould, chief executive of the Sustainable Shipping Initiative (SSI), uses the two vessels as a hypothetical. An operator may already have a crew welfare policy on file, with commitments on issues such as rest and complaints. Evidence from the actual ship would give the charterer a chance to see how those commitments work in practice at the point when there is a choice about which operator gets the business.
SSI arrived at this question through discussions with marine insurers, lenders and others whose decisions can influence the way ships are operated. Besley-Gould recalls insurers saying they could follow the sequence of events that led to a claim and still have very little information about the working conditions of the people involved. SSI went back to the existing evidence, bringing together the research in From Welfare to Risk.
The limits of the claims record
Fatigue, mental health and psychological safety emerged from the review as areas where the evidence already shows a relationship with safety. Each raises a different question about how a ship operates. A watchkeeper may have had fragmented sleep across several port calls. Another crew member may have noticed a hazard and hesitated over whether it was safe to challenge a decision. A claim recorded under the broad heading of “human element” can leave the insurer with very little detail about either set of circumstances. SSI’s conversations point to a second gap as well. Insurers need better information about working conditions before an incident if they are to learn which practices tend to be associated with later claims.
Besley-Gould describes meeting a seafarer in the Philippines who had spotted something wrong with the mooring ropes. She recalls how he explained why he kept quiet.
“I knew there was something wrong with the mooring ropes, and I couldn’t raise it because I’d been told I wasn’t important.”
Crew members also told SSI of situations in which they were expected to discuss a complaint with the superior they had reported. A person considering whether to use that procedure has to think about who will see their name and what authority the person they are reporting has over their work.
An operator can find out how its reporting procedure works by asking who receives a confidential report and what they do with it. The people on board can tell the company whether they know how to reach that person and whether past concerns were followed up. Those answers can show where the reporting process gets difficult while there is still time to do something about it.
What seafarer welfare looks like on an individual ship
When operators and charterers started discussing what good welfare might look like, Besley-Gould remembers ideas such as karaoke facilities and coffee machines coming up. The seafarers SSI spoke with kept coming back to the terms and conditions of ordinary working life. They wanted to know that pay would arrive on time and their contracts were secure. Good food and drinking water, shore leave, connectivity and a chance to sleep were among the things they raised repeatedly. Several months into a contract, the internet connection can be how a person stays in touch with family or deals with a problem at home.
There is already a way for companies to assess themselves against crew welfare standards. For its review of the seafarers’ rights code, SSI drew on 2,069 valid RightShip Crew Welfare Self-Assessment submissions from 1,072 companies, along with a survey of 892 seafarers and workshops in the Philippines. The company returns document the practices operators say they have put in place. The survey and workshops capture experiences from working seafarers. SSI presents those sources separately in its Delivering on Seafarers’ Rights progress report.
Showing how a policy works on a particular vessel takes some of both kinds of evidence. An internet subscription is straightforward to check through an invoice. For a crew member, the question is when they can get online, from where and at what cost. A ship that can answer those questions gives a prospective crew member something to work with before they agree to spend months on board. The same information lets the company check whether the service it pays for is reaching the people it is meant to serve.
How charterers and insurers could use the evidence
Besley-Gould describes work on a small set of indicators that could sit within the industry assessments operators already complete. One possibility is a shared record associated with the vessel’s IMO number. An operator could provide evidence once, and charterers, lenders or insurers could consult it when they needed to make a decision. That would depend on those groups agreeing which evidence they can use. It would also need to be clear when the evidence was collected and what period of work it describes. For example, an operator might have changed staffing arrangements since the last time the vessel served a run with a succession of short calls.
If some of that information were available to seafarers, it could help them decide whether to take a berth. They might already know the company through a previous contract and still have questions about the ship, the route or what happens when normal working arrangements come under pressure. Being able to look up the vessel would give them a starting point for that conversation before they travel to join it.
Rio Tinto uses SSI’s crew welfare self-assessment framework alongside dry bulk management standards in its Designated Owners and Operators programme for shipping partners. The company has used vessel visits, office audits and other checks to verify that partners meet programme requirements. A visit gives an assessor a chance to ask people on the ship how an arrangement works, with the office’s account already to hand. Rio Tinto sets out the programme in its marine and logistics overview and describes those checks in its reporting on chartered vessels.
The International Union of Marine Insurance has already given hull and machinery underwriters a way to ask more specific questions. Its checklist covers matters such as fatigue and access to shore support, with the aim of bringing crew wellbeing into risk assessment, underwriting and claims work. It is completed ashore by a broker or the insured’s insurance manager. The person filling it in has a reason to ask operators how the arrangements they describe are being used on their ships. The questions are available in the IUMI Crew Wellbeing Checklist.
For an insurer, checking whether particular practices predict fewer or less serious claims would take time and comparable records of both conditions and losses. The insurer would need to know what arrangements were in place at the time of a loss and how they compare with arrangements on ships doing similar work. Charterers already have a decision to make about which vessels they put their cargo on. In that setting, an operator with credible evidence of how it supports its crews can show what it has provided when the work is being awarded.
Rest through a tight turnaround
A rest-hours record has a recognised place in maritime compliance. The Maritime Labour Convention sets standards on hours of work or rest and requires daily records so compliance can be monitored. A series of short calls can make the practical question more complicated. The work of getting a ship ready to sail can run into the time set aside for a watchkeeper to sleep, especially when several jobs depend on the same few people. The records are a starting point for finding out how often that happens and what the operator does when it does. See the Maritime Labour Convention standard on hours of work and rest.
There can be pressure to produce a tidy record when it will be used to assess a ship. An assessment can make room for the days when a plan fell apart and for the crew’s account of why. If a seafarer records missed rest after an overrun, the operator can check who was told and whether work was shared differently on the next call. That sequence gives a prospective charterer evidence about the company’s response under pressure, and gives a crew member a reason to record what actually happened.
Besley-Gould would like to see commercial shipping make it easier to staff vessels so that people can get the rest they need through demanding turnarounds. A ship manager considering an extra person for a particular run has to account for the cost. What that person makes possible can be quite ordinary. An officer can hand a job over at the end of a shift and get some sleep before coming back on watch. The International Maritime Organization recognises the role of staffing and workload in its guidance on fatigue.
When a schedule regularly leaves the same person working through their rest, the senior crew may be the first to know. The people in a position to change the staffing or the timing are often ashore. A charterer who asks how the ship handled those calls can discuss a realistic port window and what coverage the operator will provide while the next voyage is still being planned.
────────────────────────────
SUPPORTED BY
CHIRP Maritime & The Seafarers’ Charity
────────────────────────────
CHIRP Maritime runs an independent, confidential reporting programme and shares safety lessons from incidents, near misses and concerns raised by people working at sea.
The Seafarers’ Charity supports seafarers and their families through grants and partnerships focused on welfare, safety and wellbeing.





Comments